Monday, December 23, 2013

‘Dead’ man back, but wife allowed to keep his job: Court Order

‘Dead’ man back, but wife allowed to keep his job

CHENNAI: It was more of a riddle than a legal battle. Railway employee Abdul Saleem went missing in 2002, leaving behind his wife Nayeeda Begum and two young children. Begum lodged a complaint with police. After seven years, as Saleem remained untraced, Section 108 of the Evidence Act was invoked and he was declared as 'presumed dead'.

Begum was now eligible to be considered for a job in the railways on compassionate grounds, and she was recruited in 2009 as a cleaner. She also got benefits such as gratuity and leave salary due to Saleem.

In 2011, Saleem resurfaced and demanded his job back. He petitioned the railway authorities to allow him to rejoin duty. He said he was working as a coolie in Hubli and could not make a decent living. Realising that he is still alive, the railways issued a termination notice to Begum, prompting her to move the Central Administrative Tribunal. The tribunal ruled in her favour saying she had not cheated the railways and she got the job only after Saleem was declared 'presumed dead'. The railways moved the high court challenging the CAT ruling.

When the matter came up before a division bench comprising Justice N Paul Vasanthakumar and Justice P Devadass, there was neither law nor precedence to decide the case.

Begum neither cheated the railways nor misrepresented facts. But, the railways cannot legally allow her to continue in the job while its employee, who had been presumed dead, was alive. The court, on its part, cannot allow its sense of sympathy to undermine law.

To complicate the matter further, while Begum and her children were ready to reunite and live with Saleem, he was not willing to take them. They, however, unanimously left the matter to the wisdom of the court hoping it would do 'complete justice' to them.

The judges then came out with a suggestion which was acceptable to Saleem, Begum and the railways. It asked the railways to retire Saleem from service compulsorily as punishment for long absence. He would be entitled to receive his pension alone. Begum would then be appointed afresh as cleaner grade-III without any other claim for service rendered since 2009. The order protected the railways' interest as well, as it cannot be accused of any lenience or illegality.

Out of abundant caution, the judges made it clear that the order had been passed on the peculiar facts and circumstances of this case and should not be treated as a precedent in any other case.
Stay connected with us via Facebook, Google+ or Email Subscription.

Subscribe to Central Government Employee News & Tools by Email [Click Here]
Follow us: Twitter [click here] | Facebook [click here] Google+ [click here]

No comments:

Post a Comment

Don't hesitate to express yourself. Please write your valuable comments.

This Month's Popular Posts

Top Generated search terms/ keywords used by our visitors to  arrive in Central Government Employee News.
* 7th Pay Commission – Estimated Pay Scales shows substantial increase in salary for CG Employees
* Projected 7th CPC Pay for each cadre/Post, Pension and all service matter: Submission of oral evidence by BPMS
* Expected Pension / Family Pension Table in 7th Pay Commission
* 7th Pay Commission will bring fortune for central government employees
* Decisions taken National Joint Council of Action meeting held on 16.02.2015 on 7th CPC, DA Merger issues
* Importance of other allowances in 7th CPC report
* Modi Government is set to big announcement on Budget in view of 7th Pay Commission Read more
* 7th CPC may recommend no increment for lazy central government employees
* Budget demand for Seventh Pay Commission Read more
* Expected DA DR from July 2015: AICPIN released for Feb, 2015
* Government refused interim relief and merger of dearness allowance, assured for 7th CPC report on time
* Meetings Schedule of 7th Pay Commission with Union/Association
* 7th Pay Commission is likely to seek extension, delay in report is expected
* What central government employees can expect from the 7th Pay Commission
* Proposal to 7th CPC: 3.7 multiplication factor, Minimum Wage of Rs.26000/-, 5% Increment rate, 5 promotions, HRA - 60%,40%,20%, Wage ratio 1:8, CEA for Higher Studies, Minimum Pension 67%
* 7th Pay commission may drop the Pay Band-Grade Pay System
* Budget: Government may relax LTC norms to boost tourism
* New Pension Scheme in Railways may be scrapped
* Pension can’t be less than 50% of pay: Supreme Court
* Guidelines for Educational Qualifications and Experience for framing/ amendment of Recruitment Rules
* Income Tax Exemption Limit in the Budget 2015-16
* Budget will decide actual date of implementation of 7th Pay Commission
* Seventh Pay Commission likely to submit report in October 2015
* Schedule for Admission in Kendriya Vidyalayas for the year 2015-16 Click for form & more
* Budget 2015: Income tax expectations for the salaried from PM Narendra Modi's government
*  Meeting by 7th CPC
* Latest on One Rank One Pension 
* Revised Railway Concessional Certificate Forms
Adhar Based Biometric Attendence System
Update on Bank Staff Wages Revision  
Usage of Other Bank's ATM: RBI Clarification
* Time to reform CGHS: An article  
* Pre-2006 Pensioner Case: Law Ministry's Advice
* Latest on Income Tax
* 7th CPC News   Terms of Reference  Composition  Demands
* Cadre Restructuring * Income Tax CBEC  * CAT Order
* Interim Relief   * Merger of DA  *  7th CPC Interim Report
* MACP on Promotional Hierarchy: Latest Update
* Pension Arrears from 01.01.2006 as per Court Order
* Frequently Asked Questions on Service Matters
* Job on Deputation/Absorption/Contract for Retired/Working
List of Gazetted/Restricted Holidays 2015
* One Rank One Pension Orders * Impact of DA Merger

All Time Popular Posts

Recent Comments