Reservation in job promotions not compulsory: Supreme Court

Reservation in job promotions not compulsory: Supreme Court

HIGHLIGHTS

  • SC refused to refer its 2006 verdict on SC/ST job promotion to a 7-judge bench
  • SC turned down Centre's plea for SC/ST to be considered for granting quota
  • A 5-judge Constitution bench pronounced the unanimous judgement


he Supreme Court today turned down an appeal to reconsider its own earlier order that had rejected the idea of reservations for Scheduled Castes (SCs) or Scheduled Tribes (STs) in job promotions.

The court today essentially upheld its 2006 order that had said that it was not mandatory for the government to give reservations in promotions in public sector jobs.

However, the court overturned one aspect of the 2006 order that had put a condition for the government to follow in case it wished to provide reservation in jobs.
[post_ads]
The Supreme Court today held that states need not collect quantifiable data on the backwardness of SCs and STs for giving quota in job promotions. The 2006 order had made it mandatory for states to collect this data in case they wished to give reservations in job promotions.

A plea had asked the Supreme Court to set up a bench larger than the one that delivered the 2006 verdict and to reconsider the idea of having reservations for SCs and STs in job promotions.

The unanimous judgment today was pronounced by a five-judge Constitution bench.

The bench headed by Chief Justice Dipak Misra said that the states need not collect quantifiable data on the backwardness of SCs and STs for giving quota in job promotion to SC and ST employees.

The top court did not comment on two other conditions given in the 2006 verdict which dealt with the adequacy of representation of SCs and STs in promotions and not to disturb administrative efficiency.

The bench had reserved its verdict on August 30 after hearing various stakeholders, including the Centre, on the matter.

A five-judge constitution bench, in its 2006 verdict in the M Nagraj case, had said the states are bound to provide quantifiable data on the backwardness of SCs and STs, the facts about their inadequate representation in government jobs and the overall administrative efficiency, before providing quota in promotions to members of these communities.
[post_ads_2]
The Centre and various state governments have also sought reconsideration of this verdict on various grounds, including that the members of the SC and ST communities are presumed to be backward and considering their stigma of caste, they should be given reservation even in job promotions.

The Centre has alleged that the verdict in the M Nagraj case had put unnecessary conditions in granting quota benefits to the SC and ST employees and sought its reconsideration by a larger bench.

Attorney General K K Venugopal, appearing for the Centre, had strongly argued in favour of granting quota to SC and ST employees, saying there was a presumption of backwardness in their favour.

He had said the SC and ST communities have been facing caste-based discrimination for long and the stigma of caste is attached to them despite the fact that some of them have come up.

During one of the hearings, senior advocate Rakesh Dwivedi, who represents those opposing quota in promotions, had told the bench that earlier there was a presumption of backwardness with regard to scheduled caste and scheduled tribe communities.

There should not be quota in promotions for higher services as the presumption of backwardness of SC and ST employees "vanishes" once they join government service, he had claimed.

Dwivedi had also said quota in promotions for SC/ST may be continued for class-IV and class-III services, but should not be allowed for higher services.

Earlier, the top court had questioned the logic behind granting quota in promotions in government jobs to the kith and kin of affluent persons among the SC and ST communities who have been holding high official positions.

It had asked why the 'creamy layer' principle, used to exclude the affluent among Other Backward Classes (OBCs) from enjoying the fruits of reservation, cannot be made applicable to deny quota benefits in promotion to those affluent among the SC and ST communities.

With inputs from PTI
Read at: India Today

COMMENTS

BLOGGER
Name

100 percent da,19,10th Bipartite Settlement,54,6 CPC Order,11,7th CPC Bunching of Stages,15,7th CPC Charter of Demands,100,7th cpc interim report,12,7th CPC Meeting,149,7th CPC Notification,202,7th CPC Projected Pay,200,7th CPC Questionnaire,16,7th CPC Recommendation,611,7th CPC Report,132,7th CPC Terms of Reference,41,8th Pay Commission,1,Aadhar,14,Absorption,46,Ad-hoc Bonus,31,Additional Allowance,4,Additional Pension,7,Additional Post Allowance,2,Administrative Reforms,17,Advance Increment,5,Adventure Sports,9,Age Relaxation,18,AGIF,5,AIIMS,13,Air Travel,74,AIRF memorandum to 7th CPC,4,Airport Employees,7,All India Service,74,Allowances,410,Alteration of Date of Birth,8,Annual Allowance,1,Antarctica Allowance,1,Anubhav,15,APAR,52,Area Welfare Officer,5,Armed Forces Tribunal,20,Army Welfare Fund,8,Artisan Staff,12,Ashok Kumar Mathur,9,Atal Pension Yojna,12,Autonomous Bodies,73,awards,15,Bank,184,Bariatric Surgery,2,Benevolent Fund,3,bhavishya,15,Bhutan Compensatory Allowance,7,Bio-metric Attendance,38,Bonus,146,Bonus Order 2014,9,Bonus Order 2015,13,Bonus Order 2016,7,Bonus Order 2017,10,Bonus Order 2018,12,Breakdown Allowance,3,BRO,16,BSNL,86,BSNL IDA Pensioner,24,BSNLMRS,5,Budget 2014,12,budget 2015,22,Budget 2016,1,Budget 2017,22,Budget 2017-18,6,Budget 2018-19,3,cadre management,24,Cadre Restructuring,194,Cancer Treatment,8,Cantonment Board Employees,3,Cash Handling Allowance,5,cashless treatment,16,Casual Leave,7,CAT jurisdiction,1,CAT Order,67,CBDT Order,30,CBEC,13,CBEC CR,9,CBSE,22,CCS (CCA) Rules,60,CCS (Conduct) Rules,57,CCS (Joining Time) Rules,6,CCS (Leave) Rules,54,CCS (RP) Rules 2008,47,CCS (RP) Rules 2016,87,CEA,41,CEA Form,9,Central Administrative Tribunal,3,Central Government Employee Calendar,32,central government employee news,39,Central Pension Accounting Office,130,Central Secretariat Service,6,Central Universities,29,CG Counsel,2,cgda,134,CGEGIS,25,CGEGIS TABLE,16,CGEWHO,65,CGEWHO Noida,18,Cghs,454,CGHS Agartala,2,CGHS AHMEDABAD,6,CGHS AIZAWl,1,CGHS ALLAHABAD,5,cghs BENGALURU,4,cghs bhopal,7,CGHS BHUBANESWAR,3,CGHS CHANDIGARH,6,cghs CHENNAI,3,CGHS Clarification,82,cghs dehradun,4,Cghs Delhi,71,cghs empanelment,170,Cghs Gangtok,1,CGHS GUWAHATI,5,CGHS HOSPITAL LIST,29,CGHS HYDERABAD,7,Cghs Imphal,1,CGHS Indore,1,cghs jabalpur,5,cghs jaipur,7,cghs kanpur,5,Cghs Kohima,1,cghs kolkata,4,cghs lucknow,3,CGHS MEERUT,6,cghs mumbai,5,cghs nagpur,3,cghs patna,4,CGHS plastic cards,12,cghs pune,2,cghs ranchi,3,cghs rates,48,CGHS Refferal System,2,Cghs Shillong,1,cghs trivendrum,5,CGWB,3,Charge Allowance,2,Child Care Leave,34,Children Education Allowance,44,CIP(IW),1,Citizen Charter,2,Civil Accounts Organisation,50,Civil Services Examination,17,cleanliness pledge,2,cmss,1,Coal Pilot Allowance,3,Collection of Order,1,Commercial Duty Allowance,3,Commercial Employment after Retirement,12,Commutation of Pension,34,commuted Leave,7,Compassionate Allowance,3,compassionate appointment,71,Compensation,1,Compensatory allowance,4,Compensatory Leave,4,Composition of 7th CPC,9,Compulsory Retirement,15,computer advance,4,computer help,7,Concordance Tables,15,Condiment Allowance,4,Confederation 7th cpc memorandum,4,confirmation,4,Constant Attendant Allowance,15,Construction-Survey Allowance,1,Consumer Price Index,10,Contingent Employee,13,Contract Labour,128,Conveyance Allowance,6,Court Order,109,CPAY,1,CPF Pensioner,26,CPGRAMS,9,CPMA,4,CPMF,102,CPSE,158,cpse ida,59,CS(MA) Rules,73,cscs,10,CSD,41,CSS,41,CSSS,14,cvc,63,Cycle Maintenance Allowance,5,DA from 01-07-2011,3,DA from Apr 2018,3,DA from Jan 2012,5,DA from Jan 2013,16,DA from Jan 2014,22,DA from Jan 2015,16,da from Jan 2016,10,DA from Jan 2017,7,DA from Jan 2018,15,da from Jul 2012,13,DA from Jul 2013,16,da from jul 2014,11,DA from Jul 2015,9,DA from Jul 2016,14,DA from Jul 2017,10,DA from Jul 2018,12,Daily Allowance,19,Daily Officiating Allowance,2,Damage Rate,1,DAPWA,1,Data Entry Operator,5,Database of Employees,2,date of next increment,56,DCMAF,4,DCRG,7,Dearness Allowance,177,Dearness Pay,3,Dearness Relief,96,Debt Recovery Tribunals,2,Defence Civilian Employees,130,Defence personnel,602,Dental Clinics,4,Department Canteen,21,Deputation,63,Desk Allowance,1,dgqa,2,Dictionary,3,Digital Signature Certificates,1,Direct Tax Code,2,Directorate of Estates,80,Disability Pension,69,Disciplinary Authority,26,DIT,9,Divorced Daughter,4,DNI falls Feb-Jun,8,Domiciliary Visit,3,doppw,4,DOPT,44,DoPT Order,453,Double HRA,8,Double Tpt Allowance,2,dpc,25,Draftsmen,4,DRDO,6,Dress Allowances,7,Dress Code,1,Dry Cell Allowance,1,e-awas,6,e-filing,31,E-Governance,14,e-HRMS,1,e-IPO,1,E-office,12,e-payment,24,E-Revision,20,e-samarth,2,Earned Leave,8,ECHS,102,ECI,1,EDLI 1995,5,edp allowance,1,EDP Cadre,12,Education,87,Ekta Diwas,2,Election,24,Eligibility of Teacher,20,email Policy,1,emergency treatment,9,Empanelment under CSMA Rules,23,Employee Pension Scheme,23,Employees Deposit Linked Scheme,1,Engineering Cadre,30,eNPS,7,Entertainment Allowance,1,Entry Pay on Promotion,33,EOL,1,EPFO,134,EPFS 1952,58,ERS,3,ESIC,25,eTDS return,15,EVC,5,ex-gratia,38,Ex-India Leave,5,Ex-Indian Coast Guards,1,EX-SERVICEMAN,662,Excel Tips,5,Exemption from Return Filing,11,Expected DA,80,Extension in Service,3,Extra Ordinary Leave,1,Extra Work Allowance,2,extraordinary pension,27,Facilitation Fee,1,Family Pension,244,Family Planning Allowance,8,FAQ,73,Festival Offer,10,Fin Min Order,160,Finance Act 2013,1,Financial year 2012-13,2,Firefighting Staff,2,Fitment Formula,75,fixed medical allowance,53,Flexible Complementing Scheme,3,Flying Training,2,Foreign Allowance,2,Foreign Visit,11,form 14,1,Form 16,3,Form 16A,2,Form 25,3,Form 26AS,2,Forms,74,Forwarding of Application,2,FR 15(a),2,FR 22,10,FR 26,2,FR 29,1,FR 35,1,FR 46B,1,FR 49,1,FR 56,19,Free Sea Passage,1,Freedom Fighter Pension,21,Fundamental Rules,4,Gallantry Award,5,GAMS,1,Gandhi Jayanti,10,GAR-23,1,GDS,87,General Pool,64,Geological Survey of India,4,GFR,37,Government Holiday Calendar,49,Govt accommodation,119,Govt Tour,52,gpf,57,Grade pay of SO,62,Grameen Bank,2,Grant-in-aid,2,Gratuity,41,Gratuity Limit for Income Tax,3,greetings,4,group A,118,Group D,76,Guest House,17,Hard Area Allowance,12,Hard Station,2,Headquarter Allowance,2,health insurance scheme,17,hearing aid,3,Hierarchy,43,High Court Order,67,Higher Education,35,Hill Area Allowance,2,Hindi Incentive,6,Holiday Homes,39,Holiday Overtime,2,Honorarium,27,Hospitality,1,Hostel Facility in Universities,1,Hota Committee,1,House Rent Allowance,35,Housing Loan,12,HRA,35,IBA,27,ICAS Officers,1,Immediate Relief,1,Immovable Property Return,61,Implementation of 7th CPC,1050,incentive for higher qualifications,4,Incentive for NER,4,Incentive to Sportsperson,14,Income Tax Exemption Limit,118,INCOME TAX,293,Income tax calculation,17,Indemnity Bond,1,Independence Day,2,India Water Week,1,INDU,4,Industrial Trades,20,Injury Leave,1,Inquiry Officer,14,insurance scheme,10,Intelligence Agencies,3,Interest of EPF,23,Interest of GPF,19,interest rate,29,Interim Relief,60,Internet facility to officer,1,Internship,3,Invalid Pension,3,Investment,2,IPv6,2,IRCTC,39,IRTSA,27,Island Special Duty Allowance,1,IT Cadre Restructuring,30,IT Return,54,ITR,5,Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya,13,JCM,375,Jeevan Pramaan,53,Joining Time,6,Kashmir Valley Special Concession,6,KBC,2,kendriya bhandar,2,Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan,182,Kilometreage Allowance,2,Kisan Vikas Patra,4,KV Admission Guidelines,22,KV Uniform,7,KYC,1,Lab Technician,17,Labour Bureau,16,Labour Laws,23,lactating mother allowance,1,laptop-notebook-facility,5,LARGESS,8,Launch Campaign Allowance,1,LDC-UDC,81,LDCE/GDCE,37,Leave Encashment,16,leave management system,2,Legal Fee,3,Librarian,2,LIC,2,Licence Fee,12,Lien,5,Life Certificate,64,List of Holidays for year 2012,2,List of Holidays for year 2013,8,List of Holidays for year 2014,10,List of Holidays for year 2015,17,List of Holidays for year 2016,11,List of Holidays for year 2017,3,List of Holidays for year 2018,5,List of holidays for year 2019,6,List of Posts,15,Liver Transplant Surgery,1,Liveries,1,loan advances,38,Loans and advances by Central Government,3,lodge complaints,5,Lok Sabha QA,42,lokpal,60,LTC,146,ltc to AN,12,LTC to JK,31,ltc to NE,24,LTC-80 Fare,30,MACP,211,Major Penalty,13,Married Accommodation Project,2,Maternity Leave,13,Medical Charges Reimbursement Bill Form,18,medical decategorization,2,Medical Examination of Group A Officers,4,Medical Professional,67,Memorandum to 7th cpc,82,merger of da,127,merger of grade pay,36,merger of post,18,Min HIPE,1,minimum wages,136,Ministerial Staff,34,Minor Penalty,8,Minority Community,1,Missing Family Member,7,Model School Organization,1,modified parity in pension,43,MOHALI HOUSING COLONY,3,Movable Property Return,50,MSP,3,MTNL,11,Multi Tasking Staff,27,NAC,118,national council meeting,14,National Holiday Allowance,6,National Level Monitors,1,National Mascot Design,1,National Pension System,128,NC JCM Memorandum to 7th CPC,31,NCH,1,NDG ESM Pensioner,1,new pension scheme,252,New Pension System,45,News,153,Newspaper Reimbursement,1,NFIR,3,NFSG,19,Night Duty Allowance,25,Nivaran,1,NLM,1,No Demand Certificate,1,Nomination Forms,6,Non-functional Upgradation,21,Notice for Pensioners,41,Notional Fixation,32,NPA,20,NSC,6,NSSF,3,Nursing Allowance,14,Nursing Institutions,6,Nursing Staff,9,nutritious dietary allowance,2,obc,39,office procedure,13,office space,5,Office Timing,51,Official Directory,1,Official Language Cadre,6,Official Secret Act,1,Officiating Pay,3,One Rank One Pension,367,Online Survey,1,Operation Theatre Allowance,1,ordnance factory,98,OROP Order,38,OTA,26,Out-turn Allowance,1,Outsourcing,9,Overpayment,7,PAC Recommendation,1,PAINTING,2,PAN,17,Paramilitary Allowance,3,Parangat,2,Parliament Assistant,1,Passport,19,Paternity Leave,3,Patient Care Allowance,16,pay,9,Pay Anomaly,73,Pay Fixation,252,Payroll,7,PCDA Order,126,PCO Allowance,2,Pension,718,Pension Adalat,23,Pension Disbursement,97,Pension Form,9,Pension Revision,322,Pensioner Grievances,70,Pensioner I-Card,13,Pensioner Portal,152,Pensioners associations,137,pensioners retired prior to 1.1.2006,163,Penury Grant,2,Permanently disabled children,22,person with disability,88,Personal Pay,5,Personal Staff to Minister,5,PF Scheme,3,PFRDA Bill 2011,25,pgportal,2,pharmacist,3,Physical Training Instructor,1,PIB,4,Piece work calculation,3,Piece work incentive,6,Piece Work Profit,2,Piece Work Rates,3,Piece Work System,3,Pilot Cadre,1,PLB,49,Pledge,7,PLR Scheme,1,Post Graduate Allowance,3,post office,211,PPF,16,PPF Scheme,10,PPO,70,Pragati,5,Pre-1996,7,Pre-2006,57,Pre-2016 Pensioners,110,pre-retirement counselling,19,Presenting Officer,1,Principal CAT,2,PRIS,22,probation,10,Professional Update Allowance,1,Project Allowance,1,Project Dantak Bhutan,3,Promotions,193,Provisional Pension,9,public grievances,8,Public Provident Fund,9,punctuality,1,Qualification Pay,4,qualifying service,41,Railway Concession Form,3,Railway Servants (Pass) Rules,26,Railways,1006,Railways Training Centre,7,Rajbhasha,38,Rajya Sabha QA,38,Rank Pay,23,Ration Money Allowance,8,RBI Circular,17,Re-employed ex-serviceman,59,Receipt Payment Rules,15,Recovery,14,Recruitment,193,Recruitment rules,179,Refreshment Rates,1,RELHS,15,Rent Free Accommodation Allowance,1,Reply to 7th CPC,12,requisition to SSC,3,Research Pay Matrix,1,reservation,150,Reservist Pension,1,residency period,4,Resignation,9,Rest Allowance,1,Restricted Leave,3,Retired Employee,52,Retired officers as Consultant,33,Retirement Adviser,1,retirement age,90,Retirement Road Map,70,review of records,2,revised pay rules,72,Right to Information Act 2012,4,Right to Information Act 2017,2,Right to Public Service Act,1,Risk Allowance,25,roster,2,Rotational Transfer Policy,15,Rounding Off,2,RTI,69,RTI Call Centre,4,rti online certificate course,2,Rule 10,1,Rule 16(3),1,running staff,40,Safai Karamcharies,1,Sainik School,3,Salary Disbursement,30,Sankalp,27,Sanskriti Schools,3,SAS Examination,7,Saving Bank Allowance,2,sc,29,scholarship Scheme,4,Schools,8,Scientific and Technical Posts,16,Scouts-Guides,4,SCOVA,67,Secretarial Assistance,1,Security Allowance,1,Self attestation,7,Self-certification,7,Senior Citizens,24,Seniority,17,Sensitive Posts,3,Service Book,15,Service Verification,6,Seventh Pay Commission,1935,Seventh Pay Commission Report,335,Sexual Harassment,27,Shramev Jayate,1,shunting duty allowance,2,Siachen Allowance,1,Sitting Fee Allowance,2,small saving scheme,56,social Media,18,Space Technology Allowance,1,Sparrow,8,Special Allowance,13,Special allowance for Child Care,2,Special Allowance for Safety Officer,1,Special Casual Leave,8,Special Disturbance Allowance,1,Special Duty Allowance,6,Special LC Gate Allowance,1,Special Pension,2,Special Train Controller Allowance,3,Split Duty Allowance,1,sports-person,39,SSC,12,st,26,Staff Benefit Fund,6,Staff Car Driver,6,Staff Selection Commission,1,Stagnation,6,State Govt Employees,2,Station Leave Permission,4,Stenographer,3,Stents,2,Stepping up of Pay,40,Stiching Charges,4,Stipend,12,Storekeeping Staff,5,Strike,239,Study Allowance,2,Study Leave,10,Substitute Employee,1,summer vacation,3,Sumptuary Allowance,5,Superannuation,11,Superannuation Charges,1,surplus employee,3,suspension,14,Swantah Sukhaya,2,Swavalamban,36,TA Rules,5,Tatkal Tickets,29,tax,2,Tax Free Bonds,1,TDS,38,TDS Rates,12,Technical Allowance,1,technical resignation,8,telephone facility,3,temporary employee,6,Tenure Allowance,4,Terms and condition,1,Territorial Army Allowance,1,Toll Free Number,1,Tough Location Allowance,5,Touring Officer Hostel,15,Trade Apprentices,13,Trade Union Act,1,train,126,Training Allowance,10,training policy,43,Transfer Policy,86,Transport Allowance,31,Travelling Allowance,71,tribal area allowance,4,Trip Allowance,2,Uniform Allowance,8,Unit Run Canteen,26,Upgradation of Post,58,UPSC,20,vacancies,29,Veteran Commission,2,Veterinary Posts,2,Vigilance Clearance,13,Voluntary Retirement,25,Wages,19,Washing Allowance,12,whistle-blowers,7,Widowed Daughter,4,winter vacation,1,Women Employees,53,Yoga,7,Youth Hostel,3,Zila Saink Board,6,वेतन आयोग,188,
ltr
item
Central Government Employee News and Tools: Reservation in job promotions not compulsory: Supreme Court
Reservation in job promotions not compulsory: Supreme Court
SC refused to refer its 2006 verdict on SC/ST job promotion to a 7-judge bench SC turned down Centre's plea for SC/ST to be considered for granting quota A 5-judge Constitution bench pronounced the unanimous judgement
Central Government Employee News and Tools
https://www.staffnews.in/2018/09/reservation-in-job-promotions-not.html
https://www.staffnews.in/
http://www.staffnews.in/
http://www.staffnews.in/2018/09/reservation-in-job-promotions-not.html
true
3718188640253144573
UTF-8
Loaded All Posts Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS PREMIUM CONTENT IS LOCKED STEP 1: Share. STEP 2: Click the link you shared to unlock Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy